The Key Insurance Team

Key Insurance of Pensacola is an independent agency that has been serving Pensacola since 1984. Our staff has over 150 years of combined experience in the insurance industry. The Key Insurance Team is committed to providing clients with the highest quality insurance plans available combined with some of the lowest rates available in all of Florida. Whether you’re shopping for auto insurance, home insurance, boat, motorcycle or RV insurance, we can help get you the best coverage available with the lowest rate possible.

Our ultimate goal is to create lasting relationships with each of our clients so that we may continue providing excellent service for many years to come.

HOME QUOTE

Whether you Rent or Own, make sure your home and belongings are properly protected. Let us help you find the right protection with a rate you can afford.

AUTO QUOTE

We know finding the right Auto coverage can be overwhelming. Our experienced agents will narrow down your options and get you the lowest rate.

SPECIALTY INSURANCE

We'll shop multiple companies to find you the best combination of price and coverage. Protect your boat, RV and motorcycle with the best insurance.

Get the coverage you need
for your peace of mind

Why choose Key Insurance?

Our experts will shop your insurance needs to find the most affordable coverage available.

Superior Service

Quality of service is our core focus, and it is the very foundation of our business.

We’re Tailored To You

Forget one-size-fits-all insurance. Get the exact protection you need, right when you need it most.

Dedicated Agents

You will receive dedicated service from a professional agent who will work to find you the best available rate and coverage.

What our clients are saying

  • Love doing business with them they always find the lowest rates.

    Alex Cooke Avatar Alex Cooke
    July 11, 2020

    Fayolyn always takes awesome care of us for all of our insurance needs! Highly recommended

    sara coker Avatar sara coker
    July 11, 2020

    My agent helped me obtain the insurance information that I needed!

    cheryl Lovelace Avatar cheryl Lovelace
    July 11, 2023

    Jessica helped me obtain insurance for my residence. She was with me every step of the way and answered all my questions. She is very knowledgeable and helpful.

    Mary Cresci Avatar Mary Cresci
    November 11, 2024
  • They are professional and amazing!!! They found less expensive home owners insurance for us!!! And we were not even looking!!!

    Mary Carter Avatar Mary Carter
    July 11, 2020

    I have been with Key Insurance for over 40 years. They put their customers first and work to provide you with the best coverage and the best companies. Paul... read more

    Marvetta Nesbitt Avatar Marvetta Nesbitt
    January 11, 2025

    Robert is an awesome guy. He will go above and beyond to find the best value for coverage. He is super hard-working guy who loves helping people. Ask for Robert... read more

    Dan Avatar Dan
    July 11, 2024

    Today, 2/6, I had the pleasure of speaking to Ms. Erica of Key Insurance, and I got more information about what to do and expect for my Home and Flood... read more

    Evelyn Bumacod Avatar Evelyn Bumacod
    January 1, 1970
  • Very good.

    Johnny Wilson Avatar Johnny Wilson
    January 1, 1970

    Prices have gone up for almost everyone but with a few changes to my policy they managed to keep me at the same cost for home insurance.

    Jeffrey Hedenberg Avatar Jeffrey Hedenberg
    July 11, 2023

    Jamie is great to work with.

    Elden Scott Avatar Elden Scott
    July 11, 2024

    I have been using Key Insurance for years, because of the stellar customer service. With the rising cost of Insurance, and lower standards of service I want to spend my... read more

    Lisa Green Avatar Lisa Green
    July 11, 2024
  • Jessica was a big help throughout the entire process of getting a new homeowners policy and saved me money on my previous policy!

    Jillian Mouser Avatar Jillian Mouser
    November 11, 2024

    I personally deal with Ann, and I really love her customer service. She is professional, sweet, and she really cares about getting you the best option that fits what... read more

    Heatherdawn Avatar Heatherdawn
    July 11, 2020

    Very helpful staff. Highly recommended.

    Christine Gary Avatar Christine Gary
    July 11, 2023

    Key Insurance of Pensacola is a fantastic insurance agency. Robert has helped us by finding better coverage with better prices. Robert is always quick to return phone calls and... read more

    Adam Bretschneider Avatar Adam Bretschneider
    July 11, 2024